20
15 Comments

Learned the hard way: your mission doesn't pay the bills

Introduction

In the past decade, I have started a handful of companies. Some of them turned out well, and some didn't. I have learned a lot. In this post, I will share how my sole focus on my company’s mission led to its downfall.

Moving to San Francisco

In the summer of 2017, my girlfriend and I left our native Switzerland and moved to San Francisco to start an education tech company. I wasn't new to the entrepreneurship game: I had started and sold a small ecommerce company when I was 22 years old, and then started another company that’s still running and making millions each year.

For reasons that I might get into another time, I decided to leave my successful company that summer of 2017 to start a new one. My previous company had a mission somewhere on our about page, but it was certainly not the main driver of our business. I wanted to work on something where the mission was more important. The new company was called Humbot, and it was extremely mission-driven: We wanted to improve science education for kids and teenagers.

I have no idea what I’m doing

The reality was, I didn’t have any experience in the education industry. I had never worked in this field and didn’t have any friends who did. On top of that, the problem we were trying to solve was very broad. Our mission was ambitious yet naive: If we can improve science education, the world will be a better place (of course, that in itself might not even be true).

The first iteration of our product was a mobile app that let users browse bite-sized explainers for different topics from physics, chemistry, and biology. While (I thought) the content was good, it was hard to distinguish our explainers from all other explainers that existed out there. Furthermore, it was impossible to monetize it.

Waking up

We later realized that we need to tackle a real, specific problem that people is ready to pay for. We pivoted to other concepts, from chatbots to tutoring apps - unsuccessfully. We were living in expensive San Francisco, and our savings and loans were going down the drain fast.

After two years, we left San Francisco and moved back to Europe (never back to Switzerland, though). I went back to my previous company to be able to pay the bills (part-time) and we continued working on our EdTech company. In the end, we were close to burning out and sick of living in debt and with so little money. After fighting for three years, we had lost the motivation to chase our mission.

Hindsight is 20/20

The moral of the story is: It’s great that you care about your mission, but never forget that to reach that mission, you need a strong foundation for your company that makes money. For that, you will need to solve an actual problem people have. Instead of setting your mission and rushing off like I did, try to find and validate a solution to a specific problem first. Only then might you have a realistic shot at making headway towards your mission and making a positive impact.

Today, I’m taking a less all-in approach to entrepreneurship. During the day I make money as a freelancer, and in my spare time I work on three projects: Fugu, a privacy-focused and open-source product analytics tool, Mapzy, an open-source store finder, and Ravioli, a reusable shipping box system for ecommerce. They all have a mission, but primarily they solve a real problem I myself had.

  1. 5

    This is great Can. Thanks for sharing. While I'm still tinkering on a lot of ideas, I can relate to you very much. I think about my mission all the time and sometimes I get bogged down in execution when I'm considering every angle of my mission and how that's reflected in my work.

    This is a great takeaway: "It’s great that you care about your mission, but never forget that to reach that mission, you need a strong foundation for your company that makes money."

    Was it difficult to evolve in your approach and focus? I want to make a difference in the world while also making money. I know it's possible but it certainly feels difficult. Thanks again!

    1. 3

      Thanks for the kind words, Jamie!

      To be honest, it was a very emotional period for me. Before having this realization, I always thought whatever I do, I need to make an absolute large impact, otherwise I have failed.

      I felt that I had a lot of pressure from society and my friends and family (even though I didn't) that I need to do something big, and doing something that just has a smaller impact would be wasting my time. Over the years, I realized that this is not true. That it's better to build a product that helps people just a bit is better than trying to change the world and failing at it.

      I realized that by taking it step by step, I can build something cool that touches many people and improves their lives, be it just by a tiny amount. That way, I could balance the mission much better with the financial aspect of the business.

      Of course, I haven't succeeded at this strategy yet. My products have a few users, but I wouldn't say they are successful yet. However, it feels much better. Let's see how this turns out =)

  2. 4

    I've worked in EdTech for nearly 20 years, it's a very difficult market to be in as a startup. The market is very fragmented, is notriously under funded and doesn't move at any way near the technological pace of other markets. Good on you for trying to innovate there.

    1. 1

      Exactly - yet so important!

  3. 3

    Hindsight is indeed 20/20. At least you went for it though! So many IHers never even try (myself included). Now you're wiser for it and your success potential will be that much higher moving forward. Cheers to failing forward.

    1. 3

      Thanks! Yes, I agree that trying is usually better than doing nothing. Would have been cool if it worked out on the first try, though :D

  4. 1

    Mis felicitaciones para usted Can

  5. 2

    Good story, greetings from Turkey :)

    1. 1

      🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷

  6. 2

    I am sorry to hear about what you have been through but I admire you so much for taking ownership and for not giving up on yourself. It would be so easy for you to be bitter, and yet, you keep learning and getting stronger.

    I made the mistake of being too mission focused before, now I remind myself that money is what pays for the mission.

    1. 1

      Thanks! It's important to take time to regroup from time to time and don't forget to enjoy life outside of your work and projects.

  7. 2

    Great story & cautionary tale!

    I suppose you must have felt passionate about science education and improving the quality of it, but you weren't really in the Ed/EdTech world so not really well connected or domain experts at all.

    Are your new side projects profitable? How are you finding customers? (say for Mapzy, the one I understand the best).

    1. 1

      I suppose you must have felt passionate about science education and improving the quality of it, but you weren't really in the Ed/EdTech world so not really well connected or domain experts at all.

      Exactly. It's not impossible to succeed in such a context, but it's much harder if you are not experienced in a domain or are very familiar with the problem.

      Are your new side projects profitable? How are you finding customers? (say for Mapzy, the one I understand the best).

      No, they are not profitable. For Fugu (the product analytics tool) I have two paying customers, but I knew them before. For Mapzy, we don't have any paying customers yet. Both are open-source and self-hofstable, and I don't know many self-hosters there are. But e.g. Fugu has currently 59 stars on GitHub (give it some love, hehe), so I hope a few people also self-host it.

      Finding customers: I'm trying to be where the customers are.
      For Mapzy, we're now building a Shopify app so that it can be discovered by Shopify merchants who want to embed a nice map in their store.
      For Fugu, it's a bit easier for me because my potential customers are exactly people like me: Devs who care about privacy and open source and don't want to use one of the big alternatives like Mixpanel and Amplitude. I get some traffic from IH, some from Hacker News (where I mention Fugu if it's relevant to the dicussion) and from Subreddits like r/privacy and r/degoogle.

      Having said that, these projects really are side projects. I only work on them if I feel like it, sometimes I don't do anything for weeks. Of course, this will change once they hopefully start to pick up more, but I'm in no hurry to get there.

  8. 2

    thanks for sharing olcer, in indonesia, we have ruangguru.com, it's edtech startup, you should check it out, they are very successful here, maybe because we have skyrocketing population with lower digital disruption

    1. 1

      Thanks! I'm not in EdTech anymore, but I'll have a look :-)

Trending on Indie Hackers
Reaching $100k MRR Organically in 12 months 29 comments 87.7% of entrepreneurs struggle with at least one mental health issue 14 comments Passed $7k 💵 in a month with my boring directory of job boards 12 comments How to Secure #1 on Product Hunt: DO’s and DON'Ts / Experience from PitchBob – AI Pitch Deck Generator & Founders Co-Pilot 11 comments Worst Hire - my lessons 11 comments Competing with a substitute? 📌 Here are 4 ad examples you can use [from TOP to BOTTOM of funnel] 10 comments